To The Management
By Ed Johnson
I am frequently frustrated and disappointed in the standard of management I am subject to. Discussions with my peers in the software industry lead me to believe that I am not alone in my malaise. So on behalf of the silent multitude of software professionals who are disappointed with their management, I would like to remind you - the project manager, team leader or technical manager - of those basic rights to which your staff are entitled.
The Right To Your Courtesy And Respect
Of the complaints I hear directed towards management, the most frequent concern dishonest, abusive or otherwise inappropriate behavior. Remember that no matter how angry or frustrated you may be feeling, it is never okay to direct that anger towards your associates. Intemperate outbursts only engender disrespect and generate ill feeling. As a leader, you are obliged to behave in an exemplary manner at all times.
Respecting your staff implies valuing their opinions, and being prepared to accept their determinations in areas where their expertise is greater than your own. It means acknowledging and accommodating the technical obstacles they encounter, rather than trying to usurp reality with authority.
The Right To Adequate Resources
Skimping on software and hardware resources is an obviously false economy, as a deficit of either impedes your most expensive resource – your people.
More commonly overlooked are such environmental resources as lighting, storage space, desk space, ergonomic aids and whiteboards. Workers quickly become dissatisfied if the basic elements of a productive environment are absent.
The resource generally in shortest supply in a software development environment is time. It’s not surprising then that unrealistic scheduling is one of the greatest sources of conflict between technical staff and their management. Please keep this in mind - successful scheduling is a process of negotiation, not dictation.
Nobody knows more about how long a particular task will take to complete than the person who is to complete it. Your team has the right to be consulted on the scheduling of those tasks they are responsible for, and to be able to meet their commitments without undue stress or hardship.
The Right To Emotional Safety
In many corporate cultures there is a stigma associated with being the bearer of bad news. To ensure that individuals feel safe in expressing unpopular truths, you must not only accept, but also welcome bad news as an opportunity to avert a more serious problem later. Ultimately, you are reliant upon others to keep you apprised of the project’s technical progress, so it is obviously beneficial to obtain their insights in uncensored form. For their part, technical staff need to feel that they can openly seek help with their problems, without risk of punitive repercussions.
In a human-based endeavor like software development, mistakes and failures are inevitable. Staff rightfully expects a compassionate attitude from you when dealing with their own failures. When they underestimate a task’s completion time, or inject a defect into the code base, they need help in correcting the underlying problem, not castigation for the symptom.
The Right To Your Support
Your staff has the right to expect your assistance in dealing with the issues they encounter. Responsiveness is paramount - issues need to be dealt with in a timely manner, before they can fester into full-blown crises. You must be willing to put aside self-regard and do whatever is necessary to resolve the issue as quickly as possible. This may mean making an unpopular decision, or entering into conflict with other managers. Without the courage and integrity to support your team in this manner, you compromise the well being of the project and the people on it.
Failure to proactively support your team’s efforts will necessarily disadvantage them. They have a right to presume you will use your experience and your high level view of the project to forecast the risks they may encounter, and prepare mitigation strategies accordingly.
The Right To Know
Your team expects decisions affecting project staffing, scheduling and scope to be communicated to them quickly and honestly. Unnecessary delays can limit their ability to respond effectively to changing conditions, with consequent stress and time pressure.
Some managers feel they have to shield their subordinates from the political machinations of their organization. This attitude betrays little respect for their team member’s maturity, and a basic ignorance of the technical personality, which values painful truths over comforting lies. Your staff has the right to know about anything that impacts on their work, so that they can maximize the chances of achieving their goals.
The Right To Self-Determination
There is nothing so disempowering as to be set goals, but have no control over the means by which one is to achieve them. This is the predicament in which you place your staff if you deny them the flexibility to tailor their work practices to the problem at hand, insisting instead on rigid adherence to methodological or corporate dogma. You may find political safety in playing it by the book, but your people want to work in a way that makes best use of their time and energy, and expect your support in achieving that goal.
It is my recurring observation that management practices that infringe upon the abovementioned rights are common. Equally common is the software professional’s lamentation that their management “doesn’t have a clue.” The two may well be causally related.
So I urge you to put aside your spreadsheets and Gantt charts for a moment and consider the rights of your subordinates. Focus on the basic principles of a humane management style - integrity, respect, courtesy and compassion. Their application cannot guarantee your success as a manager, but their absence will guarantee your failure.